The scoreboard, honestly: the hard targets, how often each one is actually looked at,
and the quiet human signals that never make it onto a dashboard.
Campaign Deployment Accuracy
Making sure emails go out to the correct segments, at the right time, with perfect content (no broken links, correct merge tags).
Target · >99.8% (fewer than 2 errors per 1,000 sends)You've sent 50 campaigns this month, totalling 1 million emails. If there are zero errors, you're at 100%. One small error in a segment of 500 emails would be a minor hit, but a major error to the whole list would be a big problem.
Email Open & Click-Through Rates (OR/CTR)
How many people open our emails and how many click on the links inside. These are key indicators of engagement and relevance.
Target · Meet or exceed channel benchmarks (e.g., 20%+ OR, 2.5%+ CTR)A recent product update email achieved a 25% open rate and a 3.1% click-through rate, which is above our usual benchmark of 22% and 2.8% for that type of content.
Unsubscribe Rate
How many people opt out of our emails. A high rate means we're probably annoying people or sending irrelevant content.
Target · Maintain below 0.3% on all campaignsAfter a big promotional blast, the unsubscribe rate was 0.28%, which is within our acceptable range, showing the content was generally well-received by the audience.
List Pull Turnaround Time
How quickly you can get a requested list or segment ready for a campaign or analysis.
Target · <24 hours for standard requests, <48 hours for complex segmentsA content team member asked for a list of blog subscribers who haven't opened an email in 30 days on Tuesday morning. You delivered it by Wednesday morning, hitting the 24-hour target.
Automated Journey Performance
The effectiveness of the automated email sequences you build, like welcome series or re-engagement flows.
Target · Increase completion rate by 10% YoY; maintain 15%+ CTR on key calls to actionOur new customer onboarding journey saw 70% of users complete all 5 emails, up from 63% last quarter, and the 'first purchase' email had a 17% CTR.
Campaign Quality & Innovation
The overall quality of the campaigns you build, including creative execution, segmentation logic, and testing methodology. Are you just repeating what we've always done, or are you trying new things?
- Proactive suggestions for A/B tests
- positive feedback from Content and Product teams on campaign setup
- successful implementation of dynamic content blocks
- willingness to try new email formats or journey structures.
Data Hygiene & Segmentation Accuracy
How well you maintain the cleanliness of our customer data within the CRM and ensure segments are built correctly.
- Zero instances of incorrect audience targeting for campaigns
- proactive identification and flagging of data discrepancies
- clear documentation of segmentation logic
- minimal manual clean-up required before campaign sends.
Collaboration & Communication
How effectively you work with other teams (Content, Data, Sales) to ensure CRM efforts are aligned and well-supported.
- Proactive communication of campaign timelines and requirements
- smooth handovers of content and assets
- positive feedback from internal stakeholders on your responsiveness and clarity
- active participation in cross-functional planning meetings.
Problem-Solving & Troubleshooting
Your ability to diagnose and fix issues within the CRM platform or campaign workflows.
- Successfully debugging broken automation journeys
- identifying root causes of data sync errors
- finding solutions to unexpected campaign performance dips
- documenting solutions for future reference.